Boost or advertise? It’s the Instagram marketing dilemma that’s probably sitting in your notification tab right now. You’ve got a post that’s performing well, and Instagram’s tempting you with that little ‘Boost’ button. But wait – should you dive into the full Ads Manager instead? Before you click either option and watch your marketing budget take flight, let’s clear up the confusion.
While both boosted posts and Instagram ads can amplify your content, choosing the wrong option is like bringing a water gun to a firefight. One might be perfect for your quick visibility boost, while the other could be your ticket to laser-focused marketing success. If you’ve ever wondered why some brands seem to nail their Instagram advertising while others see their money evaporate into the social media void, you’re about to discover why.
Let’s unpack exactly what sets boosted posts and Instagram ads apart – so you can make the smart choice for your marketing goals (and your wallet).
Ads vs. Boosted Posts
Ads and post-optimization are vital parts of an effective social media strategy for any brand. Both options can greatly influence your account’s reach, impressions, and conversions. Understanding how each option works and knowing when to use the right approach is essential.
Boosting: What Is It?
Boosting refers to the process of amplifying an existing post, making it accessible to a larger audience. It is generally easier to boost posts on most platforms than to create specialized advertising packages. Administrators and editors can boost any post with just two or three clicks, provided their payment option is set up. Boosting has become a staple for many social media teams, with most allocating a specific budget each month, week, or per post for boosting purposes.
A regular boosting approach accomplishes a number of important objectives, such as: getting more followers or likes on your page, making more impressions & boosting involvement.
Placement of Ads
Ad managers have the option to position advertisements in various sections of the social media network. Over time, you will identify which placements yield higher conversion rates, allowing you to maximize your investment at the most critical moments. Think of ad placements as the locations where users can be found.
On Facebook, these placements include
- News Feed
- Messenger
- Stories
- Reels
- Dedicated Ads Panel
New goals
Advertisements facilitate various desired actions, such as driving website clicks to boost traffic to your e-commerce store, generating leads, prompting app downloads, or offering more information about your services. This also includes tracking impressions and reach.
Audience targeting
Social media platforms enable marketers to reach specific audiences with ads at optimal times by utilizing a vast amount of user data. While this precision can be beneficial for teams with limited resources or those operating in niche markets, it also raises important privacy and security concerns.
Six Tips for Creating Impactful Instagram Posts and Ads
Creating effective boosted posts and Instagram ads is crucial for enhancing your social media presence. These tips will help you produce engaging content that resonates with your target audience.
1. Know Your Audience
Understanding your target audience is crucial before you create any posts or advertisements. Conduct market research to gather information about the demographics, interests, and preferences of your audience. This will enable you to tailor your content to meet their specific needs.
2. Eye-Catching Visuals
Since Instagram is primarily a visual platform, it’s essential to ensure that your posts and advertisements feature attention-grabbing photos or videos. Use striking designs, vibrant colors, and clear branding elements to help your content stand out in users’ feeds.
3. Strong Copywriting
Along with images, the text in your ad or post is crucial for effectively conveying your message. Craft concise yet impactful headlines and captions that spark curiosity or evoke emotion, while clearly capturing the essence of what you’re promoting.
4. Clear Call-To-Action (CTA)
Every successful advertising campaign includes a clear call to action (CTA) that prompts visitors to take a specific step, such as visiting your website, making a purchase, or signing up for a subscription. In the limited space on Instagram, make sure to clearly communicate what you want users to do next.
5. Targeted Placement
When setting up your campaigns, take advantage of Instagram’s extensive targeting options. You can choose location targeting, interest-based targeting, relevant hashtags, or even retarget users based on their previous interactions with your brand.
6. Test and Optimize
For each campaign type (such as Instagram advertising versus boosted posts), experiment with different ad formats (like carousel ads compared to single image or video ads) and variations in messaging or design elements.
To achieve better results, regularly monitor key performance indicators (KPIs) such as engagement rates, click-through rates (CTR), conversions per impression (CPI), and others.
Pros and Cons of Boosting Your Instagram Post
Are you wondering why your Instagram photos aren’t getting the responses you hoped for?
This could be due to the format, content, or quality of your posts, which may be hindering your connection with your target audience. Additionally, it’s possible that you’re not allowing enough time for audience engagement to grow, as building that connection often takes time.
However, boosting your post can be an effective solution, no matter the reason for the lack of enthusiasm from your audience.
You might be asking yourself, “Why should I invest my hard-earned money in boosting my post when I’ve already put considerable effort into creating high-quality content?”
Pros of Boosting Your Instagram Post:
1. Reach New Audiences Who Will Love Your Brand.
Even if your brand offers the perfect solution to a customer’s problem, they may not find it on their own. This is especially true if your business is still new and the customer doesn’t have friends who can recommend your products. So, how can you introduce your brand to these ideal customers?
Enhancing your content can be a great solution. By boosting a post, you can target a specific audience based on the characteristics of your ideal market. Additionally, Instagram provides an “automatic” option that selects your post’s audience based on the traits of your existing followers. This allows your content to reach a “lookalike” audience who are likely interested in your products and services.
2. Make the most of your successful posts.
Do you have a post on Instagram that you’re particularly proud of because your followers loved it? You might have looked at it and thought, “All the effort I put into creating this content was worth it!” Now, how can you capitalize on the momentum generated by this fantastic piece of content? The answer is simple: improve upon it.
While it might seem counterintuitive, promoting content that is already attracting significant traffic can be beneficial. Even if a post is performing well, the interest from your current followers may decline quickly, especially if your follower count is not in the thousands. Therefore, it’s important to refresh your content and keep it relevant on Instagram for a longer duration.
Cons of Boosting Your Instagram Post
Every action, including those on social media, has its benefits and drawbacks. Here are some potential downsides you might encounter when promoting your Instagram posts.
1. You can only target one audience at a time.
Successful marketing relies on identifying the ideal target market for your products, which is possible when you boost a post on Instagram. However, what if you want to replicate the post and share it with a different audience?
2. There are limited promotion objectives to choose from.
Naturally, every business aims to increase website traffic, promotion views, and profile visits. However, if your primary interest is in improving conversion rates, simply boosting posts may not be effective.
Additionally, the quality of the content you are boosting and the audience you select are just two of many factors that can influence the results of post boosting. If you think that boosting won’t adequately meet your advertising needs, consider using Instagram Ads instead.
Pros of Instagram Ads
Instagram Ads offer a more advanced method for brand promotion. Here are some specific benefits of running ads on Instagram:
1. Enhanced Audience Targeting
The Instagram Ads Manager tool provides superior audience targeting compared to the audience selection options for boosted posts. While boosted posts only allow you to select an audience based on age, location, and interests, Instagram Ads, being fully integrated with Facebook Ads, give you access to Facebook’s extensive formatting and campaign customization options.
This integration allows you to take advantage of Instagram’s high engagement rates while also utilizing a wide range of targeting options. With Instagram Ads, you can create different audience personas and tailor your content to meet the interests and needs of these diverse audiences.
2. Track the Performance of Your Campaign
You can access comprehensive and up-to-date information about your Instagram advertisements through the Ads Manager. This tool allows you to see which campaigns are generating the highest levels of engagement. It also provides insights into your spending and earnings, as well as the number of leads and purchases resulting from your ads. Additionally, when you create Instagram ads, you have the ability to customize them and set specific goals.
Overall, by continually using Instagram paid advertising, you can adjust and optimize your ads to achieve the best possible results.
Cons of Instagram Ads
1. Instagram is mobile-friendly and visually appealing.
While Instagram can be accessed through a web browser, uploading images requires the use of a mobile device. This may be inconvenient for your social media manager. Additionally, Instagram’s focus on photos and videos may not suit businesses that produce primarily textual or written content. Instead, Instagram can be used to tease content and drive traffic to your website.
2. Instagram has a limited audience.
The majority of Instagram users are young and predominantly female. If this demographic does not align with your target audience, Instagram may not be the best platform for your business.
Choosing the Best Option for Your Company
Deciding between Instagram Ads and Boosted Posts for social media advertising can be challenging.
Both options can effectively help you reach your target audience and offer unique benefits. To make the best decision for your company, consider the following important factors.
First, clarify your advertising objectives. Are you looking to drive more traffic to your website or increase brand awareness?
If you have specific goals, such as generating leads or promoting a new product, Instagram Ads may be the better option. They allow you to create customized call-to-action buttons and provide advanced targeting options.
Boosted posts can be an effective option if your goal is to increase engagement with your current followers or reach a wider audience on Instagram.
Setting them up directly from your Instagram profile is simple and hassle-free. It’s also important to consider your budget. Compared to running full-fledged Instagram ads, boosted posts are generally less expensive.
Therefore, boosting could be an appealing choice if you have limited resources but still want to enhance the visibility of your content. Additionally, think about how much control you want over the creative aspects and placement of your advertisements.
Instagram Ads offers a variety of ad formats, including photo, video, and carousel ads, as well as different placements within users’ feeds.
This variety can enhance the effectiveness of your messaging and give you greater control over how your content is presented. It’s essential to monitor performance metrics closely.
Any advertising solution you choose should provide comprehensive analytics to help you accurately assess the effectiveness of your campaigns.
The robust reporting features available through Facebook Ad Manager and Instagram Ads Manager enable data-driven decision-making based on real-time results.
Recommendation:
Both Instagram Ads and Boosted Posts are valuable tools for enhancing your social media presence. However, selecting the best option for your business depends on understanding the differences between the two and identifying your advertising goals.
Instagram Ads offer greater customization and targeting options, allowing you to reach a specific audience with tailored content. You can create interactive and engaging ads that drive conversions, utilizing features such as carousel ads and call-to-action buttons.
In contrast, Boosted Posts are quicker and easier to set up. They can help increase the visibility of your posts to your existing followers or to a targeted audience based on their interests or demographics. Once you’ve made your choice, you can proceed to launch your advertisement.
Last Updated on March 6, 2025
Subscribe And Receive Free Digital Marketing Tips To Grow Your Business
Join over 8,000+ people who receive free tips on digital marketing. Unsubscribe anytime.
